1. Forms
2. CP
3. CP-04-15

CP 04 15 - Utility Services – Direct Damage Endorsement

The CP 04 15 Utility Services – Direct Damage endorsement is a crucial addition to a Commercial Property policy. Its primary purpose is to provide coverage for direct physical loss or damage to the insured's covered property caused by the interruption of specific utility services. A key feature of this endorsement is that the interruption must originate away from the described premises. The endorsement requires the insured to select which utility services are covered, such as water supply, power supply (including electricity, gas, or steam), and communication supply services, and to specify whether overhead transmission lines are included for these services. Without this endorsement, standard commercial property policies typically exclude loss due to off-premises utility failure.

Applicable Classes of Business

This endorsement is particularly vital for businesses where an interruption of utility services could lead to immediate physical damage to property, including stock, equipment, or buildings. Examples include:

• Manufacturing Operations: Businesses that rely on a continuous power supply for machinery, where a sudden shutdown or startup could cause direct damage to the equipment itself (e.g., damage to production lines, sensitive electronic components).
• Food Processing and Cold Storage: While spoilage due to temperature change is often covered by a Utility Services – Time Element endorsement (for business income/extra expense) or specific spoilage coverage, if the interruption of power directly damages refrigeration equipment (e.g., power surge upon restoration damages compressors), the CP 04 15 could respond to the equipment damage.
• Businesses with Climate-Sensitive Materials: Operations like greenhouses, pharmaceutical manufacturing, or certain chemical storage facilities where a loss of power or water directly damages plants, products, or materials due to the inability to maintain critical environmental conditions. For instance, if a power outage causes a pumping system to fail, leading to a tank overflow and water damage to other property.
• Data Centers or Technology Companies: While business interruption is a major concern, a sudden power surge or outage could physically damage servers, networking gear, or other sensitive electronic equipment.

Special Considerations

Several important factors must be considered when utilizing the CP 04 15 endorsement:

• Selection is Key: Coverage only applies if the specific utility service (Water Supply, Power Supply, Communication Supply) whose interruption caused the loss is scheduled on the endorsement. Furthermore, if damage results from an interruption of power via overhead lines, "Overhead Transmission Lines" must also be selected for the Power Supply service. Failure to properly schedule the relevant utility or transmission line type can result in an uncovered loss.
• Direct Damage Trigger: This endorsement covers direct physical loss or damage to Covered Property. It does not cover loss of business income, extra expenses, or consequential losses unless these result directly from physical damage covered by this endorsement (and even then, the business income aspect would typically require a separate Utility Services - Time Element endorsement like CP 15 45). For example, if a power outage causes a machine to malfunction and physically break, that breakage is a direct damage. However, the lost income from the machine being down is not covered by CP 04 15.
• Off-Premises Origin: The interruption of the utility service must originate away from the described premises. Issues originating on the insured's property (e.g., a transformer owned by the insured failing) are generally not covered by this endorsement but may be covered under the main property form.
• Covered Cause of Loss: The interruption itself must result from a peril that would be covered under the policy (e.g., a windstorm damaging a substation). However, some versions of the form may provide coverage even if the cause of the utility interruption is unknown.
• Waiting Period: While not explicitly stated in the summary, policies may include a waiting period (e.g., 24 or 48 hours) before coverage for utility interruption kicks in. This should be verified in the specific policy language.

Key Information for Agents and Underwriters

Agents and underwriters should pay close attention to the following when dealing with the CP 04 15:

• Risk Assessment:
  • Evaluate the insured's dependency on each utility service. Which interruptions would cause direct physical damage, not just inconvenience or income loss?
  • Assess the reliability of local utility providers and the nature of the infrastructure (e.g., prevalence of overhead lines in storm-prone areas).
  • Inquire about the insured's backup systems (e.g., generators, uninterruptible power supplies). While these mitigate risk, they don't eliminate the need for the endorsement if the backup systems themselves can fail or be overwhelmed, or if the utility interruption causes damage before a backup can engage.
• Coverage Gaps:
  • Clearly explain the "direct damage" limitation to clients, ensuring they understand it doesn't cover lost profits or most spoilage claims (which need different coverage).
  • Emphasize the importance of selecting all relevant utilities (water, power, communications) and the overhead transmission lines option if applicable. A common oversight is not selecting "Overhead Transmission Lines" for power, which can lead to a denied claim if an overhead line is the point of failure.
  • This endorsement does not cover damage to the utility company's property itself.
• Underwriting & Pricing:
  • The selection of utilities and the inclusion of overhead lines will directly impact the premium.
  • Businesses with highly sensitive or valuable equipment susceptible to damage from utility interruptions (e.g., certain manufacturing, tech, or healthcare facilities) may warrant higher premiums or specific underwriting scrutiny.
  • Consider the geographic location and its susceptibility to events that could cause utility disruptions (e.g., hurricanes, ice storms, earthquakes).
  • Review the insured's loss history related to utility interruptions.
• Form Specifics: Always refer to the specific edition date of the CP 04 15 and any state-specific modifications, as policy language can vary. Ensure the limits provided are adequate to cover potential direct damage losses from a utility failure.